Community in Focus Find a local Morehead business or service. Your local business guide. Support Local! Hicksville, NY Homes For Sale, Long Island Real Estate Search for Homes for Sale in Hicksville NY, Long Island. Tucson See the Most Goodfield Recent Hicksville, NY Properties. Search Olive-Branch by Price Range and Lifestyle. See all ilable Homes. Bay Shore, New York Wikipedia Bay Shore is a hamlet and censusdesignated Southgate place CDP in the Town of Islip, Suffolk County, New York, United States. It is situated on the South Shore of Long.